Monday, January 17, 2011

Looking into Fire


This morning, Orlando said, "Let's save energy and light a candle and put it here on the table and have the light from the windows and that will be enough."

Last year, during the winter, we used candles in the morning instead of turning on our lights. He remembers.

So I lit a candle and put it on the table, and Mica could barely restrain himself, "I want to blow it! I want to blow it!" but Orlando wanted to blow it out, too. And as the many dozens of times a day when two boys want the same thing, we try to remember and stop and ask ourselves, "What can we do?"

Orlando's idea was that Mica could blow it out and I could light it again, and then Orlando could blow it out. So that is what we did.

I don't remember if that was before or after we ate the oatmeal, but in the midst of the candle-worshiping, I was cooking oatmeal for breakfast, and the kids wanted to help me, and we all tucked into the corner where the sink and stove meet and filled the pot and put it on the stove, and the click-click-clicking of the gas stove burst into flame, and breakfast was on its way.

And then Orlando was spinning around the living room/dining room (not far from the kitchen) wondering aloud, "I wonder why fire is different colors."

He stopped, "I mean, the fire on the stove looked blue. But when I was looking at the candle, it wasn't blue."

I jumped up and got the question book. Already, he was following the scientific method — he had his question and he was making observations.

So, I started writing things down...

QUESTION:
Why is fire different colors?
Why is it sometimes purple and blue?

OBSERVATIONS:
Fire is usually red and orange and yellow.
Sometimes it is purple and blue.
I noticed it was blue on the stove, with a little orange and purple.
In candles, I noticed it was red and orange and yellow.

HYPOTHESES:
Maybe because the stove — a stove is different than a candle.
A stove uses gas, and a candle uses a wick. {Thanks, Mama.}
Maybe they are different kinds of fire — gas makes a different kind of fire.
Maybe it's because they are different sizes. The candle flame is smaller.
Maybe it is hotter on the stove.
Maybe because one is wax.

We hadn't gotten around to developing ways to test these hypotheses, yet. Who knows what happened (marble run, restaurant, baby dinosaurs, some drawing?) in the hours from then until I re-lit the candle to take a picture for the blog, but Mica noticed that there was blue in the flame of the candle. Aha! Another observation, which will help us come up with different hypotheses, which we can then find a way to test, or at least research.

Books are already on their way from the library. He's ready to ask a few folks in the community for their theories, and we'll see where we end up.

In the meantime, I'll leave you with this, something Orlando said as he gazed into the candle flame this morning:
I just like that look, that standing-up look. It's like a sword or a letter opener. I like that. I just like the way those things look. That kind of pointiness, like standing-up.
{Can you even believe it?!}

life up close

12 comments:

  1. Right on! Tonight, Z and I were reading "The Tarantula Scientist" (part of the incredible Scientists in the Field series by the Smithsonian) and the featured scientist talked about how he really disliked "science" as a kid because he thought it meant "knowledge." Then, he realized as a college student doing his first field research project that doing science is really the process of asking questions. Your kids are figuring that out a lot sooner, in a beautifully organic way.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am pretty sure that the reason for at least some fire color change is the oxygen count. If you have access to a Bunsen Burner then you can see this.( as you open the valves on the burner the flam not only gets higher but also changes color because of the oxygen being let into the flame.) Also, the chemical make up of the thing being burned can cause fire to change colors. (there is actually a product to change the color of a fire's flames.) I hoped that this helped in some way.

    P.S. I most definitely suggest looking up the flame color changing product. Sadly, I cannot remember what it was called, but with two children it will surely bring some excitement. It did with me and I'm grown, physically at least, but mentally I am still a child.

    ReplyDelete
  4. HA! that is very funny....this is so great to
    "watch", this natural process of figuring it all out.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey, thanks for the info, Anonymous! I've already been researching a bit about why and finding out ways we can discover more through experiments. I also read about things you can add to the fire to make it change colors. We'll see if I can find a way to do this on a small, safe scale. :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. AWESOME quote at the end. that sums it up for me- i am a scientist by trade, so i think of things analytically to some extent, but at the end of the day, it's the wonder and joy of it (the poetry about flames and how wonderful it is that they are always 'standing up') that makes us even care to find out.

    ReplyDelete
  7. You have awesome kids! What wonderful observation skills they have! I completely agree with the stand up pointiness of the flame - it's awesome and mesmerizing.

    The asking questions reminded me of the book by EB White called The Trumpet of the Swan. In that book, the boy has a ritual of asking himself a question each night before he goes to sleep...

    ReplyDelete
  8. I love the idea of a question book. I think I am going to try that with my 3 year old. Thank you for an awesome post.

    -Alyson
    www.peacefulmamma.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. I love little boy questions during those moments. So much thinking to do!

    And, with two boys, we often re-light and BLOW!!!!! :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. I could sooo relate to the "what can we do?" collaboration amidst struggles to be first, to have first, to do first. And we re-light and we allow lighting and blowing on their own, and sometimes we all light and we blow together:-) There can be so many variations to happiness and ease.

    I loved the unschooling science too. We do that, and I loved how your free-thinking boys are carving their own paths of discovery, and I really love how you are able to let it all unfold gracefully, messily or however it happens to roll...

    I struggle at times with not giving answers or offering up knowledge in an area where I share interest. Mostly I have come a long way here, and find it easy enough to celebrate the wonder with them, or to ask, "yeah, why is that?" in a miraculous voice, and let them uncover, unearth and dig deep.

    Thanks Stacey for reminders to stop, and watch, to observe more often, and for helping me to remember the blessings of learning alongside my boys...

    ~Erin x

    ReplyDelete
  11. The question book is such a good idea. I remmeber after you mentioned it before I thought, "must start one of those." I think I did too, must unearth it.

    I also struggle (as Erin commented) on offering up what I do know...or even sometimes of researching what I don't. Thanks for sharing how beautifully organic it can be. Your boys are such gems...as are you. xo

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi! I recently found your blog and I love reading your posts for their honesty and inspiring accounts! The idea about the question book is very thoughtful.....the time we have with our children is so precious, documents such as these go a very long way....Thanks for sharing your stories.....I am mom to 2, and I recently started blogging : http://sprigblossoms.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for commenting! I welcome your stories, ideas, realizations, experiences, questions, and differences of opinion... I love watching the conversation develop and the connections deepen. So, thank you!